Reserve Now! Pricing and availability may change.

Prime Storage - Farmingdale

2091 New Highway, Farmingdale, NY 11735
Rating Badge
4.5
(37)
Rating Badge
4.7
(285)
Online Move In Icon
Online Move-In AvailableRent online, skip the counter, and go straight to your space

Available Storage Units (18)

5x5

$0.84 / sqft
Features
Climate Controlled2nd FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$21.00
$41.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x5

$2.88 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled2nd FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$72.00
$79.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x5

$3.56 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled2nd FloorInterior
$89.00
$99.00Only 2 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x6

$4.17 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledAlarmADA Accessible1st FloorInterior
$125.00
Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$1.88 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled2nd FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$94.00
$98.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$2.06 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledPremium Location2nd FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$103.00
Only 2 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$2.06 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledPremium Location2nd FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$103.00
$106.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$2.42 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$121.00
$136.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.17 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled2nd FloorInterior
$117.00
$169.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.34 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledPremium Location2nd FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$134.00
$187.00Only 3 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.50 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$150.00
$204.00Only 2 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.50 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledAlarmADA Accessible1st FloorInterior
$150.00
$204.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.69 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledPremium Location1st FloorInterior

First Month FREE

$169.00
$235.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x15

$1.75 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$262.00
$335.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x15

$1.93 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$290.00
$358.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x20

$1.84 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$369.00
$394.00Only 3 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x20

$2.58 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Outdoor Access
$515.00
$595.00Only 2 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

20Long

Vehicle unit
Features
VehicleOutdoor-uncovered
$168.00
$191.00Only 2 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

Complete Amenities & Features

About Prime Storage - Farmingdale

Prime Storage offers clean, secure, and affordable self storage units in a variety of sizes to fit your needs, whether you're moving, decluttering, running a business, or storing seasonal items. Many of our locations also offer climate controlled units and vehicle storage for cars, boats, RVs, and motorcycles. Month-to-month leases, online account access, and friendly local teams make storing with Prime easy. When Life Demands Space, Prime Storage is here to help.

ACCESS

  • 24-hour access24-hour access
  • Handcarts or dolliesHandcarts or dollies

SECURITY

  • On site office at facilityOn site office at facility

OFFICE HOURS
SundayClosed
Monday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Tuesday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
ACCESS HOURS
Sunday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Monday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Thursday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM

VEHICLE STORAGE REQUIREMENTS

  • Requires titleRequires title
  • Requires registrationRequires registration
  • Requires insuranceRequires insurance
  • Must be drivableMust be drivable

PROPERTY COVERAGE

  • Insurance requiredInsurance required
  • Protection Plan available for purchaseProtection Plan available for purchase
  • Homeowners or renters insurance acceptedHomeowners or renters insurance accepted

PAYMENTS

  • CashCash
  • Credit cards accepted: Visa, Mastercard, AMEX, DiscoverCredit cards accepted: Visa, Mastercard, AMEX, Discover
  • CheckCheck

BILLING

  • Email invoicing availableEmail invoicing available
  • Automatic payments availableAutomatic payments available
  • Rent due on same day each month per lease startRent due on same day each month per lease start

MISCELLANEOUS

  • Moving supplies for saleMoving supplies for sale
  • Paperwork can be done remotelyPaperwork can be done remotely

Customer Reviews

4.5(37)
Verified (37)Google (285)

Highly Recommended Storage Facility

by PR

June 27, 2025

5.0

I recently signed up for a storage unit at the Farmingdale location and had an outstanding experience, thanks to James. From the very beginning, he was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and patient throughout the entire process. He took the time to answer all of my questions thoroughly and provided a detailed overview of the facility. James even walked me through the building, showing me the entrance, elevator, and taking me all the way to my unit on the second floor. Along the way, he pointed out everything I needed to know, making the entire experience seamless and stress-free. His friendliness and professionalism were truly appreciated. The facility itself is easy to find, convenient location spotless—clean, odor-free, and cool. My unit was in perfect condition: great location, perfect size, and exceptionally clean. I’m beyond satisfied with both the service and the facility and would highly recommend Prime Storage in Farmingdale to anyone in need of storage solutions.

Easy access, very clean, professional staff

by John

November 3, 2024

5.0

Facility allows easy access to storage unit… full size dolies make moving boxes easier.

Overall good

by patrick gonzalez

October 17, 2024

5.0

Great experience and reasonable price.

nice clean location

by 浩步

July 19, 2024

5.0

Location seems like it is clean and secure

Thank You

by Justin Zorn

January 2, 2024

5.0

Just rented one month here first month was free it only cost me $29.99

William McKeever's profileWilliam McKeever
October 2, 2025

Just moved out after five happy years with Prime Storage (moved out because the kids have finally taken all their "stuff" to their own places). Throughout the 5-year tenure billing was effortless, and the staff was always helpful. James (General Manager), has been superb in every respect, especially in helping me with the move-out process. I would highly recommend him and Prime Storage to anyone who needs safe and secure storage from a reputable company with great staff!

Starlighthustle's profileStarlighthustle
March 4, 2026

Marisa was very helpful setting up my new rental. Friendly and efficient. Made me feel welcome.

Caroline Manwaring's profileCaroline Manwaring
December 24, 2025

I needed a storage unit so the most important things I held on to after I had to uproot my life were safe and secure. James was extrememly professional, curteous, and helpful with aiding me to select the appropriate unit. I felt at ease knowing that my most precious belongings were stored in a safe location and that I no longer had to worry about where it was all going to go.

Joe Albino's profileJoe Albino
March 31, 2026

The first time I had no issue. The second time I came to drop off furniture at 8:30pm the keypad to the units was broken and the second door wouldn’t open even either. Called the number and they gave me the emergency override code and that didn’t work either. What good is a storage unit if it can’t be accessed?

Charlotte Davis's profileCharlotte Davis
October 27, 2025

I've rented a few storage areas from them over the past few years and have never had a problem. Management is nice and the facility is well kept with adequate lighting.

How to Rent a Storage Unit With Storage.com

There are two easy ways to secure a unit at this storage facility

1You can complete your rental process online today and go straight to your unit when you plan to move in.
2You can make a reservation today with no payment until you sign your lease at your move-in date.
How It Works
Search icon
Select your storage unit
Reserve icon
Reserve for free

Cancel or change your reservation at any time, risk-free

Move in icon
Move in