Reserve Now! Pricing and availability may change.

Extra Space Storage - 4155 - Garden City - South St

1 South Street, Garden City NY 11530
Online Move In Icon
Online Move-In AvailableRent online, skip the counter, and go straight to your space
Discount Icon
1% Military discount
tooltip icon
1% Military discount (applies to active-duty only)

Available Storage Units (21)

4x5

$1.55 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$31.00
$33.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x5

$0.24 / sqft
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorSkyboxInterior
$6.00
$9.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x5

$1.28 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior

Flash Sale

$32.00
$34.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x6

$1.60 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$48.00
$51.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x6

$3.77 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$113.00
$120.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

4x11

$2.45 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$108.00
$115.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x9

$2.47 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$111.00
$117.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

9x5

$2.47 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$111.00
$117.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x9

$3.24 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$146.00
$155.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x5

$2.40 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$120.00
$127.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$2.40 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$120.00
$127.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x5

$3.18 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$159.00
$168.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x11

$2.36 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$130.00
$138.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x6

$2.32 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$139.00
$147.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$2.21 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$221.00
$234.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$2.92 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$292.00
$307.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x12

$2.04 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$245.00
$260.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x13

$1.88 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$245.00
$260.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x15

$1.81 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$271.00
$287.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x18

$1.82 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate ControlledUpstairs via ElevatorInterior
$327.00
$341.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x20

$2.54 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Climate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$507.00
$512.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

Complete Amenities & Features

SECURITY

  • Video cameras onsiteVideo cameras onsite
  • On site office at facilityOn site office at facility
  • Resident ManagerResident Manager

OFFICE HOURS
SundayClosed
Monday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Tuesday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Thursday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday9:00 AM – 5:30 PM
ACCESS HOURS
Sunday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Monday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Thursday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday6:00 AM – 10:00 PM

VEHICLE STORAGE REQUIREMENTS

  • Requires titleRequires title
  • Requires registrationRequires registration
  • Requires insuranceRequires insurance
  • Must be drivableMust be drivable

PROPERTY COVERAGE

  • Insurance requiredInsurance required
  • Insurance available for purchaseInsurance available for purchase
  • Protection plan requiredProtection plan required
  • Protection Plan available for purchaseProtection Plan available for purchase
  • Homeowners or renters insurance acceptedHomeowners or renters insurance accepted

PAYMENTS

  • CashCash
  • Credit cards acceptedCredit cards accepted
  • CheckCheck

BILLING

  • Email invoicing availableEmail invoicing available
  • Automatic payments availableAutomatic payments available

MISCELLANEOUS

  • Mail or packages acceptedMail or packages accepted
  • Moving supplies for saleMoving supplies for sale
  • Paperwork can be done remotelyPaperwork can be done remotely

What People Say About This Facility

Reviews originally collected from the SpareFoot Marketplace.

5 out of 5 stars
9 Total Reviews
Made storing my stuff easy

by Marianna Rigos

February 2, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Itテ「竄ャ邃「s an overwhelming task to have to move stuff but so happy I have a clean safe place to put them. Very satisfied with everything

Clean, well-maintained, and easily accessible

by Bedis Zormati

November 25, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Life Storage located at 1 South Street in Garden City offers excellent storage solutions with a high level of convenience and security. The facility is clean, well-maintained, and easily accessible, making it a great choice for anyone looking to store their belongings. Customers appreciate the helpful and professional staff, as well as the modern security features, including video surveillance and gated access. With various unit sizes and flexible rental options, Life Storage in Garden City ensures that youテ「竄ャ邃「ll find the right storage solution for your needs. Overall, it's a reliable and trustworthy option for both short- and long-term storage.

Easy move in!!!

by Jennifer Mungavin

October 28, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Amazing customer service, super clean facility

Flexible

by Erica

July 5, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

I got to the facility and realized I would need more space than the unit I reserved. The manager was kind enough to switch me to another unit on the spot.

Quick, easy, straight to the point!

by Emma Pappas

May 10, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

I reserved a unit to move my college dorm stuff for the summer. The process was extremely easy and the employee was very helpful. The move in process was also very simple and to the point. Good pricing and my first month was free.

How to Rent a Storage Unit With Storage.com

There are two easy ways to secure a unit at this storage facility

1You can complete your rental process online today and go straight to your unit when you plan to move in.
2You can make a reservation today with no payment until you sign your lease at your move-in date.
How It Works
Search icon
Select your storage unit
Reserve icon
Reserve for free

Cancel or change your reservation at any time, risk-free

Move in icon
Move in